Dealer vs Locksmith

Dealer vs Locksmith: Lost Car Keys

When every key is gone, here is how the dealer and a mobile locksmith compare on towing, speed, and cost for an all-keys-lost replacement.

Dealer vs Locksmith 5 min read

Why lost keys are different from a spare

Making a spare while you have a working key is quick. Losing every key is a bigger job, because the car has to be convinced to trust a brand-new key with no existing key present. That extra step is where the dealer and a locksmith really start to differ in time and hassle.

With no working key, the car will not start and may need to be entered first. How you get a fresh key made, and whether the car has to move, is the heart of this comparison.

The towing question

The dealer route usually means getting the car to their service department. With no key, that often turns into a tow, which adds cost and time on top of the key itself. You also wait on their schedule, which can stretch the no-start out for days.

A mobile locksmith comes to wherever the car is sitting in West Palm Beach, whether that is your driveway, a lot, or the roadside. We make and program the new key on site for most vehicles, so there is usually no tow at all. That is often the single biggest reason people call a locksmith for lost keys.

Cost, speed, and the honest exceptions

An all-keys-lost job costs more than a simple spare no matter who does it, because of the extra security steps involved. As a general rule the dealer is pricier and slower, while a locksmith tends to be faster and more affordable, and skips the tow. We give an exact quote for your year, make, and model before we start, so call us for a real figure.

We stay honest about limits. Most all-keys-lost cases are something a mobile locksmith handles, but some newer or luxury models are dealer-level by design. If yours is one of those, we will tell you up front instead of leaving you stuck.

Still have a key or fob question?

Tell us your year, make, and model and we will confirm exactly what your vehicle needs before we head out.

Back to the Knowledge Base

Frequently asked questions

Can a locksmith make a key if I lost all of them?

For most vehicles, yes. We can enter the car, then cut and program a brand-new key on site even when no working key is left. A few newer or luxury models are dealer-level for all-keys-lost, and we will say so honestly.

Will I have to tow my car to the dealer?

For the dealer, often yes, since the car cannot start without a key. A mobile locksmith comes to your location and makes the key there, which usually avoids the tow entirely. That saves both money and time.

How fast can lost keys be replaced?

A locksmith is frequently same-day and often within hours of your call. The dealer may need to order the key and schedule you, which can take days. Call us with your year, make, and model so we can confirm the timeline.

Locked Out? We're on the Way.

Don't wait around. Our mobile technicians are stationed throughout West Palm Beach ready to dispatch to your location immediately.